PA Court Rejects Lawsuit to Abandon California Standards for Heavy Diesel Engines


On November 22, the Commonwealth Court in Harrisburg dismissed an effort by the trucking industry to force the Department of Environmental Protection to drop California’s emission norms for heavy diesel engines. The state Environmental Quality Board had declared in 2002 that Pennsylvania will adhere to California’s regulations. Judge Ellen Ceisler of the Commonwealth Court, in her decision, stated that the Department of Environmental Protection has opted to halt the enforcement of these new regulations until the emergence of the 2027 model year vehicles. However, this pause does not shield truckers from legal disputes initiated by the third parties, she noted. The DEP is also at liberty to initiate the enforcement of these rules whenever it wishes.

The lawsuit filed by a small trucking company from Berks County argues that the decision to align with California standards should be termed illegal. It asserts that Pennsylvania’s Air Pollution Control Act doesn’t have clauses that allow establishing standards based on those from another state. The state’s lawyers have countered this by stating that the lawsuit ought to be dismissed as the regulation isn’t being enforced currently.

Concurring with this argument, the Commonwealth Court judges dismissed the case. They did, however, suggest the possibility of the truckers re-filing the lawsuit. The lawyers for the truckers mentioned that if they decide to re-file, they would contest the constitutionality of the language that hinders pre-enforcement challenges to the law.

Attorney Luke Wake, representing the truckers from the Pacific Legal Foundation, stated, “Only Pennsylvania holds the power to legislate laws that govern its citizens and enterprises, not California. We shall continue to advocate for our client’s rights to abide by the laws enacted by their state legislature, not by external regulators.”

Why this is significant

In June 2023, the Department of Environmental Protection (Department) announced they would suspend enforcement of 25 Pa. Code Chapter 126, Subchapter E (relating to Pennsylvania Heavy-Duty Diesel Emissions Control Program) until January 2, 2026. The Pennsylvania Heavy-Duty Diesel Emissions Control Program (Program) applies to the manufacturers of new heavy-duty diesel (HDD) engines that are used in vehicles with a GVWR of greater than 14,000 pounds sold within Commonwealth. The Pennsylvania Program adopts California Air Resources Board (CARB) regulations by reference. This means policy adopted by California can automatically be implemented in Pennsylvania.

Clean Air Act Section 177 allows other states to adopt California’s motor vehicle emission standards. Section 177 requires states that choose to do so must adopt emission standards identical to the California standards. Currently, 17 states (New York, Massachusetts, Vermont, Maine, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Washington, Oregon, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware, Colorado, Minnesota, Nevada, Virginia, and New Mexico) and the District of Columbia, representing 35.9 percent of all new vehicle sales sold in the U.S., have adopted various aspects for California’s vehicle emission standards.

CARB’s Advanced Clean Fleets Rule and its associated Advanced Clean Trucks (ACT) Rules, which mandate increased sales of Zero-Emission Vehicles (ZEV) for states that adopt them, have not been adopted in Pennsylvania. However, Pennsylvania has adopted CARB’s Omnibus Low-NOx Rule. This significantly curtails NOx emissions by revising the emissions standards, altering testing procedures, and modifying other related requirements for heavy-duty diesel engines effective in 2024.

The June 2023 DEP suspension of enforcement will allow vehicles and engines subject to the Program that have not been issued a CARB Executive Order and which meet the Federal HDD emission standards to be sold, leased, offered for sale or lease, imported, delivered, purchased, rented, acquired or received in this Commonwealth during the suspension beginning with model year (MY) 2022 and ending with MY 2026. This suspension of enforcement supersedes the suspension notice published at 51 Pa.B. 7000 (November 6, 2021). The Department’s exercise of enforcement discretion does not protect a manufacturer, distributor, seller, renter, importer, leaser or owner of a retail outlet from the possibility of legal challenge by third persons under 25 Pa. Code Chapter 126, Subchapter E.

Legislative Attempts to Repeal 25 Pa. Code Chapter 126, Subchapter E

Two bills were introduced in the 2023-2024 to remove Subchapter E from 25 Pa. Code Chapter 126 which would separate Pennsylvania from automatically adopting California Air Resources Board (CARB) regulations. Senate Bill 254 (Yaw – R) passed the Senate 29 – 20 in March 2023 and had no consideration within the House Transportation Committee. House Bill 1978 (Causer – R) was introduced in January 2024 and had no consideration within the House Environmental Resources & Energy Committee. This legislation would need to be reintroduced in the 2025 – 2026 session and would most likely have a similar challenge in passing both chambers in the divided General Assembly.